Article Sharing

  • Home
  • Shares
  • OEM Knowledge
  • What are Surfactants? A Professional Analysis of SLS, SLES, and Mild Amino Acid Formulations: A Cosmetic Contract Manufacturing Perspective

What are Surfactants? A Professional Analysis of SLS, SLES, and Mild Amino Acid Formulations: A Cosmetic Contract Manufacturing Perspective

272026.04
What are Surfactants? A Professional Analysis of SLS, SLES, and Mild Amino Acid Formulations: A Cosmetic Contract Manufacturing Perspective
What are surfactants? Professional analysis of SLS, SLES, and amino acid mild formulas [Skincare OEM Perspective]

Surfactants directly determine the mildness, foamability, and consumer repurchase rate (usage experience) of cleaning products. SLS and SLES are not monsters, and full amino acid formulas are not absolutely skin-friendly—what truly affects product competitiveness is "complex ratio design" and "compatibility between formula and skin type." Taiwan Mei Wang has nearly 30 years of experience in skincare OEM/ODM. This article explains the characteristics of surfactants from an OEM R&D perspective, deconstructs common ingredient myths, and assists brand owners in making evidence-based formula decisions.


1. What are surfactants? Why do they affect product mildness and feel?

Surfactants are the core ingredients of cleaning products such as facial cleansers, shampoos, and shower gels. They have both hydrophilic and lipophilic properties. The molecular structure possesses a dual structure of a "hydrophilic head" and a "lipophilic tail," which can mix oil and water together to achieve emulsification, dispersion, and foaming effects.

What are surfactants? Professional analysis of SLS, SLES, and amino acid mild formulas [Skincare OEM Perspective]

In skincare OEM/ODM development, surfactants are the skeleton of cleaning products. Whether developing shampoo, shower gel, or facial cleansing products, the first step of R&D must be to define this core ingredient. Excessive cleaning power will take away too much of the skin's natural oils, leading to barrier damage, dryness, or sensitivity issues. Therefore, in formula design, the selection and ratio of surfactants are crucial to providing appropriate cleanliness and a good washing experience.


2. What are SLS and SLES? Do they really need to be completely avoided?

SLS and SLES are the most common anionic surfactants, widely used in cleaning products:

Item Description
SLS (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate) Strong cleaning power, small molecular size, higher irritation. Currently, its usage proportion in facial products has gradually decreased; it is mostly used in industrial cleaning, dish soap, and other high-strength cleaning supplies.
SLES (Sodium Laureth Sulfate) A product modified from SLS through "Ethoxylation," with lower irritation than SLS.

In skincare manufacturing practice, there is no need to exclude SLS/SLES entirely. According to the U.S. Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) assessment, they are safe for use in cosmetics under appropriate concentrations and correct formula conditions. Therefore, there is no need to blindly pursue "SLS/SLES-free"; one should return to product positioning, formula design, and overall ratio adjustment.


3. Why is "mild shampoo" or "mild shower gel" not equal to a "full amino acid formula"?

With Taiwan Mei Wang's nearly 30 years of skincare OEM experience, many brands request the development of "full amino acid" cleansers in pursuit of ultimate mildness. However, such products actually have limitations. It is helpful to understand the pros and cons of amino acids more deeply:

  • Amino Acid Advantages:
    • Mild and low irritation, excellent skin affinity.
    • Post-wash feel is moisturizing without a strong sense of dryness or tightness.
    • Relatively environmentally friendly biodegradability.
  • Amino Acid Disadvantages:
    • Weaker cleaning power; slightly insufficient oil removal for oily skin.
    • Poorer foamability, lacking dense bubbles, with a slippery feel during rinsing; some people may feel they are not clean.
    • Easily affected by temperature, environment, and water quality.
    • Expensive cost.

According to multiple studies in the "Journal of Cosmetic Science," a single surfactant often finds it difficult to balance cleaning and skin affinity. Although full amino acid formulas sound perfect, in actual product development, "complex blending" is often superior to "single ingredients" and more cost-effective.

[OEM Consultation] Create a balanced and perfect shampoo formula
[OEM Consultation] Quality Wash: Customized complex shower gel formula 


4. Mild does not mean expensive: Avoid "single amino acids" and adopt complex development strategies

During initial OEM negotiations, we delve deeply into the target audience's living environment and specific scenarios (e.g., exercise volume, climate region, etc.). Through this detailed development process consultation, we can assist customers in developing truly "suitable and effective" products, reducing the risk of customer complaints from the source and building deep brand trust.

Skin Type Problem Professional Formula Suggestion (Surfactant Combination) Development Suggestion
Oily Skin Active sebum secretion, acne-prone SLES (Primary) + Betaines (Secondary) Utilize the strong degreasing power of SLES to clean pores, combined with betaines to balance dryness; best value for money.
Dry/Sensitive Skin Prone to dehydration, damaged barrier Amino Acids (Primary) + APG or low concentration SLES Maintain moisture with amino acids, supplemented by APG to increase foam richness, reducing the cost pressure of pure amino acids.
Infants/Children Thin skin barrier Amino Acids (Primary) + APG Design formulas based on age layers; cleaning power for ages 0-6 and 6-12 will differ.
Atopic Skin Damaged barrier, pathological dryness Non-ionic (APG) + Plant-derived oils Formula should be as simplified as possible, primarily using low-irritation APG.

[OEM Consultation] Gentle Protection: Maternal and infant hypoallergenic cleanser development
[OEM Consultation] Efficient Purification: Mild and non-drying hand soap R&D


5. Shifting from "ingredient myths" to "wash experience"

In the skincare market, consumers might care about the "ingredient list," but what determines a repurchase is whether the "sensory experience" is good. Rather than chasing ingredients, it is better to return to the product's sensory experience level.

As a professional skincare OEM/ODM partner, Taiwan Mei Wang suggests that brands should consider the characteristics of the target market audience and market positioning from the following items when planning cleaning products:

  • Geography and Climate: For the same "mild facial cleanser," the formula ratio must be completely different in humid and hot Taiwan compared to dry and cold Japan. Knowing more ensures the product performs stably.
  • Target Audience Skin Condition: Oily, dry, sensitive, normal, aging, infant/child skin, etc.; design appropriate formulas matched to skin type issues.
  • Sensory Preferences: Bubble texture and scent can be adjusted according to target audience preferences.
  • Specific Environments and Lifestyles: After high-intensity exercise, heavily polluted work environments, swimming/water activities, etc.

A good product does not necessarily use the most expensive raw materials. Through a detailed front-end consultation process, Taiwan Mei Wang locks in the target audience positioning and preferences. We transform complex surfactants into commercial competitiveness that meets market demand, helping you create truly "useful" star products with "repurchase power." Want to learn more? Welcome to contact us.


6. Common FAQ

Q1: Are SLS and SLES carcinogens?
No. The U.S. Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) and the EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) have issued multiple reports stating that SLS and SLES are not carcinogenic substances.


Q2: Does an ingredient list containing SLS/SLES mean the product is definitely harmful to the skin?
No, it depends on the concentration and formula. In rinse-off products, the risk of skin damage is even lower.


Q3: Is an amino acid cleanser a guarantee of "absolute mildness"?
Not necessarily. pH value and the quality of additives must be considered. According to research in the "International Journal of Cosmetic Science," the mildness of a cleanser is greatly affected by the pH value. If the pH of an amino acid cleanser is improperly adjusted (toward alkaline), or if poor-quality additives are used to increase foaming, it can also cause damage to the skin barrier.


Q4: Does more foam mean a cleaner wash?
There is no positive correlation between foam volume and cleaning power. The amount of foam is more about satisfying consumer psychological expectations and usage experience.


[References]

  • Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR) Safety Assessment
  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA): 1,4-Dioxane in Cosmetics: A Manufacturing Byproduct.
  • International Journal of Cosmetic Science
  • Journal of Cosmetic Science Archive
Back
Maybe you would like read more:
Top